Login / Register
ORNo Account? Register here.
The Case Against Matt Ryan
Our new franchise quarterback seems almost infallible. But after all we’ve endured as Falcons fans, we needed to be sure. We found evidence of serious infractions. Excessive modesty. Habitual freeloading. Conduct unbecoming a millionaire. We even got this from Ryan’s own brother: “He’s not perfect.”
Besides, moral history is against him. In the past two decades, two other Falcons quarterbacks were poised for greatness. Both left in disgrace. One was Roman Catholic, just like Ryan, and he could throw the ball seventy-eight yards even with a tired arm. Like Ryan, his first professional pass went for a touchdown. But it was scored by the other team. He caroused his way out of a job. The Falcons ditched him after one season. He was one of Ryan’s boyhood heroes. His name was Brett Favre.
Ten years later we had Michael Jordan in shoulder pads, the man who turned the Georgia Dome into an amusement park. No one in football ran faster or threw harder. Late in 2002, when ESPN asked fans to name the most dynamic person in all of sports, he got more votes than everyone else combined. That winter he marched the Falcons to Lambeau Field in Green Bay, Wisconsin, where Favre had gone to become a mortal god, where no visiting team had ever won in the playoffs, and Michael Vick trampled the Packers. His blood-red No. 7 jersey still hangs in my closet. I wear it once in a while, when I want to masquerade as a multiple felon.
“Oh, he’ll be wonderful for your city,” Ryan’s fifth-grade teacher told me on a raw spring day in Exton, Pennsylvania, his hometown, where I traveled to investigate our franchise quarterback. Others said the same. My notes began to repeat themselves:
“You’re not gonna find dirt.”
“No dirt. No dirt. There really isn’t.”
“Not gonna find any dirt.”
But one person dared to challenge convention. He is Joe Perrott, a Freudian psychotherapist. I met him in a conference room inside the old stone walls of the William Penn Charter School in Philadelphia, the Quaker high school where he taught Ryan in a course on developmental psychology. The school was founded by William Penn himself back in 1689, and its official seal carries these words: Good instruction is better than riches.
“It’s a pleasure to see someone deserving get what they deserve,” Perrott said, referring to the success of Ryan, one of his favorite former students. And then, as an afterthought, he added, “I think Brett Favre is a horse’s ass.”
When I asked him for the psychological basis of Ryan’s success, he said it must be rooted in the first five years of his life. Everything must have gone right.
“Shame and guilt are the twin horrors of childhood,” he said. “I’ll bet Matt got no shaming at all.”
“He’s totally unafraid of adverse public opinion.”
Then he said something even more intriguing. Ryan was simply too much fun to be a choirboy.
“I just don’t buy that he’s a total straight arrow. I’ll bet if you fished around, you could dig up some dirt.”
Upon further review, I must concur with Joe Perrott.
This is the indictment of Matthew Thomas Ryan.
Count I: Suppression of Evidence
Count II: False Advertising
High school: Baseball, junior year, state tournament. The Quakers have made it further than expected—all the way to the final game—and suddenly find themselves out of pitchers. “I’ll pitch,” says Ryan, even though he has never started a game before, and he throws a complete game, and the Quakers win the championship.
College: A television camera catches him vomiting on the sideline, an act that Matty Ice has conveniently postponed until after the play on third-and-twenty, with eleven seconds left and his team losing 10–7 to Virginia Tech, when he rolled to his left to escape the marauding linemen and then somehow planted his feet and threw back to the right, nearly forty yards in the air, a rainbow in the cold rain, for the winning touchdown.
Falcons: We were losing to the Bears, 20–19 on a late touchdown, and the scar tissue around my heart was throbbing again from all those years of Falcons trauma, my Battered Fan Syndrome, and then I looked up and saw six seconds left and we had one more shot. No team but the most desperate will put the ball in a rookie’s hands, but there he was, a shade under six foot five, with smooth cheeks and slender arms, barking out the play. We needed twenty-five yards. The Bears came with the fury of hell, Tommie Harris barreling toward him as fast as 295 pounds can move, and Matty Ice let the ball go just as Harris drove him to the turf.
If you look at the video now, you can see the receiver, Michael Jenkins, at the forty-five-yard line when Ryan begins his delivery, and at the thirty when he hauls it in. Ryan had to lead him by fifteen yards and lay the ball in a tiny crease between the corner and the safety and the sideline, which he did, which is why NFL Films analyst Greg Cosell called it the best throw in the league all season. We won the game with a field goal as time expired, and Ryan became the first rookie quarterback since the NFL merger in 1970 to start his first six games and win at least four, and the pressure subsided around my heart.
Anyway, the false advertising. There he was in the hunting blind, with his instructor, Chris Redman, the good ol’ boy from Kentucky who preceded Ryan as starting quarterback. Redman enjoys riffing on the nickname when they play golf. Sometimes it’s Matty Slice, which is not quite fair since Ryan recently shot a round of 71, and sometimes it’s Matty Fire, because of the time he disturbed a fire-ant bed and ran screaming across the fairway.
Dusk was falling, and Ryan gripped the rifle. The locals said a massive buck had been roaming the forest, but the buck was not in sight. A doe appeared. Redman encouraged Ryan to fire. The pressure mounted. A venison dinner hung in the balance. Matty Ice breathed hard and his hands shook. He lowered the rifle. They ate Thanksgiving dinner at Chick-fil-A.
Count III: Public Display of Affection
Motts: You’re the best older brother anyone could have. Thanks for being my biggest fan.
John: You got the house to yourself, enjoy. Never change, you are the nicest kid ever.
Pop: Thank you for your support and advice. I’ll always remember to play with a bat, ball, and a glove, not my mouth.
Whitney: The past two years have been incredible. I want you to know that where ever our paths take us, you will always have a special spot in my heart.
Count IV: Brainwashing
Ryan tries to keep their relationship private, but he did mention her this year when he showed up on Last Call with Carson Daly:
Daly: You’re out here in L.A. working with Axe Hair?
Daly: What-what-why? (Laughter from the audience.) What is that? You look good. You wear a helmet all the time.
Ryan: That’s the key . . . I’m spending most of my time in the helmet, and I teamed up with Axe Hair, postseason (waves hand at own head), to kinda get my act together off the field, and, and, um, they’ve done that. I mean, I’ve used some of the product. It’s been great. My girlfriend loves it.
Ryan: Which is huge. I mean, it’s big to keep her happy.
Daly: Well, let me say, and this may be a bit of a gay moment, but your hair looks beautiful. It looks fantastic.
Ryan: Likewise! (More laughter from the audience.)
At any rate, Whitney is now an ex, and we all know that exes dish the best dirt of all. She went on to become director of communications at the National Foundation for Celiac Awareness. Here is her response to my interview request:
I am going to respectfully decline your invitation to interview, and wish you best of luck on the profile. I am sure it will be wonderful!
Count V: Suppression of Evidence (Again)
—Joe PerrottUnlike the home-run hitter in baseball or the high scorer in basketball, the football quarterback is helpless without his teammates. No quarterback—not even an escape artist like Michael Vick—can consistently succeed without good linemen to protect him and good receivers to catch his throws. If a receiver turns the wrong way on a timing pattern, or fails to look up, or breaks off the route too soon, he is not penalized on the stat sheet. The quarterback is. Even a perfect pass can become an interception.Matt Ryan threw nineteen interceptions in 2007, his last year for Boston College. That was part of the reason he did not win the coveted Heisman Trophy and most of the reason I was skeptical when the Falcons drafted him third overall the following spring. The boos nearly drowned out the cheers when the commissioner made the announcement. Many fans would have chosen Glenn Dorsey, the defensive tackle from LSU, over a quarterback with the apparent habit of giving away the ball.
But this is why fans don’t run the Falcons. The statistics were misleading. Boston College offensive coordinator Steve Logan analyzed footage of all nineteen interceptions and found that eight of them—more than 40 percent—were not Ryan’s fault. Furthermore, at Logan’s direction, Ryan threw a phenomenal number of passes that season (nearly forty-seven per game), and many of them were extraordinarily difficult, like the off-balance rainbow that sank Virginia Tech. Some coaches ask their quarterbacks to simply “manage the game”—that is, be safe and avoid mistakes. “If he’d managed the game,” Logan said, “we’d have won about three or four less games.”
More remarkably, Ryan had done the opposite in high school. He threw the ball only occasionally. His head coach, Brian McCloskey, gave him the latitude to call any play he wanted at the line of scrimmage, and Ryan usually chose to hand it off. In the league championship game of his senior season, a 35–21 victory for Penn Charter, running back Tony McDevitt gained 328 yards and four touchdowns. Ryan threw for just thirty-four yards. “It’s nice to put up big numbers, don’t get me wrong,” he told the Philadelphia Daily News after the game, “but it’s more important to win.” Tall quarterbacks are prized by college and pro scouts because they can see over massive linemen. Had Ryan not been six foot five, that might have been the last game of his football career.
The football makes a sound when it leaves Ryan’s hand, a slight whistling hiss as the laces revolve. He does not throw hard by NFL standards, but his receivers in high school were unaccustomed to such velocity. He never punished them for dropping the ball. In fact, he often threw right back to the butter-fingered wideout, just to restore his confidence.
“Oh, it’s my bad,” he would say, even though they both knew whose bad it really was.
Count VI: Conduct Unbecoming a Recent Millionaire
I asked him, “Does Matt Ryan drive a cool car?”
“No,” he said, with something like scorn. “He drives a Ford truck. And then I think it’s free.” (Apparently he has a sponsorship agreement with a local dealership; Ryan was hesitant to provide details.)
“He don’t even have a Gameday Car,” White said. On the Falcons, and possibly around the NFL, many players keep a special car just for Sunday drives to the stadium. As such, the Spanish Gold Chrysler is not Roddy White’s Gameday Car. That job belongs to his black Maserati.
Michael Turner’s Gameday Car: a Mercedes SL coupe. Michael Jenkins comes in a Porsche; Jamaal Anderson in a Bentley; John Abraham in a Ferrari. And Matt Ryan, who could buy any of these vehicles with less than one week’s pay?
“We are trying to work on him,” White said. “He don’t care.”
“Even when we go out to dinner, he wants to watch the tab.”
It was time to ask Ryan about all this. I set up an interview for 8:45 one morning, but there was a communication mix-up and Ryan showed up at 8:10. He’d been waiting idly for twenty-five minutes by the time I arrived, which, at roughly $60 a minute, had cost the Falcons $1,500 worth of wasted time. I tried to explain, but his handlers told me to get on with the interview.
Ryan was sitting at a wooden desk in a vacant office across from a dry-erase whiteboard. Morning light poured through the window behind him. He had a tall Styrofoam cup full of a steaming beverage, and despite the theft of his precious time, he was smiling as if nothing was wrong.
I fumbled for my list of questions and my digital recorder. My heart pounded and my hands shook. What followed was perhaps the worst interview I have conducted in eight years as a reporter.
Me: Um, wondering if you could tell me about, uh, your Ford truck.
Ryan: Ford truck.
Me: Roddy White was telling me a little about, uh, about your vehicle. We were talking about his, he’s proud of his car, and I said, “Does Matt have a cool car?” and he’s like, “Naw, he drives a Ford truck.”
Ryan: (Brief chuckle.) I think it’s pretty cool. (Laughter around the room.)
Me: And when you say, um, you go home after, after practice, and you have dinner, I mean, do you cook for yourself? Or does somebody cook for you? How does that work?
Ryan: Uh, sometimes. Sometimes I cook. Um, my girlfriend cooks a lot too, ummm, or it’s takeout. (Brief chuckle.) The Carrabba’s is right down the street, so I get Carrabba’s (chuckling pause) a good amount. Ummm, Whole Foods, go to Whole Foods a lot, so, you know, those are just some of the different things. That’s kinda, I think it’s a lot like everybody else, you know, sometimes you cook, sometimes you grab something real quick. I’m a big Subway guy.
[ON LIKE THIS FOR A WHILE]
Falcons Spokesman: Hey Tom, we got about five more minutes, buddy. He’s got a session at nine he’s gotta go to.
[A FORGETTABLE EXCHANGE]
Me: Thanks for the interview.
Ryan: Good seein’ ya.
Me: Really appreciate it.
Ryan: Yeah, no problem.
Me: Is this gonna be, do you think we can talk again at all, or, uh . . .
Spokesman: We’ll work on it.
Ryan: We’ll get that set up, so . . . I’m gonna run in, but it was good seein’ you, man.
Me: Really good to see you, Matt.
Ryan: Take care.
Count VII: Accessory to a Little White Lie
“My problem was getting the girls to leave him alone.”
Mrs. Stanton pointed to a yearbook photo around which she had glued rays of construction paper in Falcons black and red. Beside the picture, all those years ago, Matthew listed his goal in life: To be a professional football player.
She said Matthew’s life is a lesson to her students. Dream big and work hard. Nothing is impossible.
“Every once in a while, you’ll have a little bugger of a student and he’ll say, ‘Mrs. Stanton, Mrs. Stanton, was this Matt Ryan’s desk?’ And I’ll say, ‘Sure.’ It’s just a little white lie.”
Count VIII: Excessive Modesty
This is a learned behavior, and unsurprising for someone who majored in communications with grades good enough to win Boston College’s Freshman Male Scholar-Athlete Award in 2004. His uncle John Loughery, a quarterback at Boston College before Ryan was born, told him it was part of a quarterback’s job. Deflect praise when possible. For someone of Ryan’s acumen, it’s almost always possible.After far too many hours reading Ryan’s quotes and watching footage of his interviews, I began to wonder how genuine this persona was. I asked several people close to him how Interview Matt compared with Regular Everyday Matt. They swore there was no difference.And yet there are glimmers of an ego behind the veil. Last year, the Philadelphia Inquirer published an anecdote from Ryan’s predraft party at a hotel in Manhattan, during which Ryan and his old high school coach, Brian McCloskey, had a private conversation. This is how the Inquirer put it:
“He told me, ‘I’m going to be the best quarterback in the history of the NFL,’” McCloskey said earlier this week. “As I stood there and listened to him, I believed him.”
When I mentioned this to McCloskey, he said he had been misquoted. (Ashley Fox, the reporter, stands by the quote.) Fine. But in the yearbook Mrs. Stanton showed me, each student got to write one short statement, and this is the one thing eighth-grade Matthew Ryan chose to write:
It’s not bragging if you’ve done it.
Count IX: Unsanctioned Enjoyment
But before retiring on the eve of his solo concert, he did some rehearsing. He went online to study some lyrics. And in the team meeting room the next day, he sang the Aerosmith tune “Janie’s Got a Gun,” the Rick Springfield classic “Jessie’s Girl,” and Journey’s “Don’t Stop Believin’” with passion and authority.
Mind you, Ryan is neither a crooner nor a choirboy. But he held nothing back. He wailed on his air guitar. He turned his face to the ceiling. He roared. Humiliation? No. Ryan was clearly enjoying himself.
“This sucker was pretty good,” Chris Redman said later. “It kinda made me mad.”
Count X: Habitual Freeloading
In any case, Exton is twenty-seven miles west of Penn Charter, a long drive through morning rush hour, and young Matt Ryan used to carpool with the Rogers family. He was always chipper, even at 7 a.m., which of course is a rarity in a fourteen-year-old, and he greeted Mr. Rogers with an enthusiastic, “How ya been?” Mr. Rogers made Taylor Pork Roll sandwiches for breakfast, and he usually had an extra one for Matt, because he knew Matt loved Taylor Pork Roll.Granted, Ryan was never late, and he brought in the paper and took out the trash, and he let the Rogerses’ English bulldog, Max, jump into his lap, and he made sparkling conversation with Mr. Rogers’s seventy-eight-year-old mother-in-law, who was on oxygen, but there is no evidence he ever paid Jack Rogers a dime for those Taylor Pork Roll sandwiches.
Count XI: Disorderly Conduct
“That’s his belief, huh?” Mike said. “I’m not sure—yeah, that’s an interesting theory. I’m not sure everything went right but, I mean, there were, you know, our guys grew up regular. You know, regular, middle-class, happy kids.”
I asked him if Matt ever did anything wrong.
“Yeah, he did. And he was by no stretch of the imagination a saint. He was a regular kid. You know, yes. Many things wrong. Oftentimes called on the carpet.”
I asked him what incident came to mind. Mike Ryan thought for a moment, then said something about Matt getting in some kind of a schoolyard scuffle when he was eight or ten. Details were scarce.
“Probably about nothing,” he said, “and I don’t think anybody took the time to find out what it was about. Nor did it matter.”
When the tour ended, he dropped me off in the parking lot of the Holiday Inn Express.
“I don’t have any tremendous revelations to give you,” he said, which meant I still had no story about Matt’s early childhood, and only two more people to ask.
Count XII: Reckless Endangerment
Second-and-goal from the six-yard line. Falcons lead 17–7. Three receivers bunched to the left. Ryan back to pass. Looks left. Looks left. Nobody open. At the twelve he puts the ball down and takes off running. Three yards from the goal line he is cornered by two purple defenders. Does he curl up? Does he slide? No. Even with a ten-point lead and at least one more available down, Ryan leaps.Naturally, a Viking takes out his knees. This is what good Vikings do in the face of an invasion. Ryan flips in the air and lands on the goal line, headfirst, losing the ball in a pile of bodies, and I hold my breath, hoping against spinal fracture.Back to that story in a moment.
I met Motts Ryan at Panera Bread near the Philadelphia Main Line, seven hours before my scheduled departure. He was even better-looking than his little brother, with short, sandy hair that stood on end with no crusty evidence of styling product. He works in the family business and has diversified into real estate on the Jersey Shore. He is still Matt’s best friend. They talk on the phone almost every day, which means, among other things, that like his father he understands the rules of media management: Smile and cooperate, but never stop circling the wagons.
During a discussion of Matt’s success, however, he did make one revealing statement. He said it casually, without much elaboration: “It’s a lot of luck too. Everything seemed to work out for Matt.”
This is more profound than it first appears. Luck, happenstance, divine providence: However you explain it, the game of life does seem rigged in Matt Ryan’s favor. Just look at his career compared with two relatives who also happen to be quarterbacks.
Matt’s uncle John Loughery was also a starter for Boston College, almost thirty years ago, and he taught Matt how to hold the football: softly, leaving a gap in the well of the palm, relaxing the index finger from knuckle to tip. Uncle John injured his hand before his junior season. He was replaced by Doug Flutie.
Motts Ryan (real name: Michael) was a quarterback too, for Widener University, faster and more agile than Matt but five inches shorter. He and Matt used to spend hours in their backyard practicing fade patterns and punt returns. On May 19, 2001, two days after Matt’s sixteenth birthday and just after Motts’s freshman year in college, they were waiting to make a left turn into the Kimberton Golf Club when another car smashed Motts’s Volkswagen Jetta from behind and shoved it into the path of a National Guard fuel truck. Motts was knocked unconscious. The Jetta’s engine caught fire. Matt got out and tried to put out the fire with his windbreaker. Fortunately, someone had a fire extinguisher. Motts was extracted from the wreckage with the Jaws of Life. He suffered a fractured skull, a broken left hand, a broken right humerus, and a shattered right elbow. He had six surgeries to try to fix his elbow. No luck. He never played football again. His brother walked away with nothing more than a broken ankle.
And the ball kept bouncing Matt’s way. He learned from a quarterbacks coach in high school, Mike Samuel, who led the Wisconsin Badgers to Rose Bowl victory. He studied under a head coach in college, Jeff Jagodzinski, who had been offensive coordinator for Brett Favre in Green Bay. He took a vicious shot to the sternum against Clemson that knocked his helmet off, but he got up and won the game. Perhaps he came to believe nothing could go wrong for him. In February 2008, the NFL held a coin toss to determine which team would get the third pick in the draft, where Ryan was projected to go. Some players might have seen Atlanta as a snake pit right then, with Vick gone to prison and their last coach, Bobby Petrino, having fled in the night. Guess what Ryan said when he heard the Falcons had won the toss:
“Tails never fails.”
The rest is familiar. The Falcons, picked by the Sporting News to go 1–15, finished 11–5, made the playoffs, and came within one third-down stop and one good drive of knocking off the Arizona Cardinals, who themselves were a toenail from winning the Super Bowl. Ryan was named NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year.
But first he had to finish his foolhardy play against the Vikings, the one where he leapt for the goal and landed helmet-first. He got up, unharmed, and his teammate Justin Blalock recovered the fumble in the end zone for the touchdown that sealed the game.
“Don’t ever do that again,” Roddy White told him when he returned to the sideline. With a six-year contract worth $72 million, Ryan is too valuable to be risking his neck. When I mentioned that play to my brother, however, he said something that probably sums up the sentiment of the fans: “It just made me love him more.”
Count XIII: Unauthorized Discovery of Christmas Presents
—Joe PerrottHere is the only story I know about Matthew Ryan’s early childhood. It comes from his sister, Kate, who loves him dearly. One Christmas morning, when she was eight or nine and Matthew was three or four, she persuaded him to defy family tradition. Santa Claus had come the night before, leaving unwrapped presents on the living room floor. Consequently, the Ryan children were expected to wait at the top of the stairs until their parents got up around 7:30. It was barely 6 a.m. when Kate led Matthew down to the living room.
She is not certain what her Santa gift was that year. Possibly a ten-speed bicycle. But she remembers that Matthew got a bouncing horse.Justice was swift when the violators were discovered. Kate was sent to her room to wait till the others finished opening presents. For her, it was the worst Christmas ever. But Matthew stayed downstairs with his new toys, bouncing on his new horse, and as far as I know he got no shaming at all.
Count XIV: Suppression of Evidence (Yet Again)
Just before dinner, as guests arrived in their BMWs and Escalades, I sat down with Ryan for a short interview in a private dining room. I asked him about that Friday
“Seemed like there were a couple of interceptions that day,” I said. “Do you remember what happened?”
He knew exactly the plays I meant, and he had ample opportunity to tell me why they were busted. But he did not.
“That’s the way it goes sometimes,” he said. “You’re gonna throw some interceptions.”
And then, after claiming he would not sing that night, he took the microphone for a guest spot on a teammate’s rendition of “Don’t Stop Believin’.” The melody escaped him, but he roared on, eyes to the ceiling, jugular pulsing, holding nothing back.