Bon Appetit gathers reviewers’ opinions on citizen criticism


A couple weeks ago, Bon Appetit’s restaurant editor Andrew Knowlton emailed me and asked if I’d send him a couple lines about my opinions on “citizen criticism” (restaurant reviews on Yelp, blogs, etc.). It turns out, he compiled quite the list of quotes from traditional media critics around the country—some with rather frank views.

Take a look and tell me: What do you think about these opinions, and about cit-crit in general?

(Image courtesy of